River Is the Hero. Lamb Is the Organizer.
Why the leaders who keep saving the day often leave their organizations weaker
By Dan Fisher, PhD and Mia Behrens, MA
Last month we used Mick Herron's Slow Horses to look at how leaders make decisions when the facts won't hold still. We're going back to the show for this one, because it keeps poking at a question most leadership writing skips past: who is actually doing the leading? (Spoilers ahead, through season 4.)
For anyone who hasn't watched: Slough House is where MI5 parks agents who have blown something badly enough to stall their careers. Jackson Lamb runs the place, if "runs" is the word. He sits in a dark office eating, drinking, napping, and insulting whoever wanders into range. River Cartwright is the one you're meant to root for. He's young and good at the job, his grandfather was a legendary spymaster, and he badly wants to get back to Regent's Park. Whenever something dangerous is happening, River is usually sprinting toward it.
So if you scored leadership by effort and screen time, River wins easily. But watch what his effort produces. Again and again, his urge to fix the thing himself makes it more dangerous for everybody else. Lamb, who looks like he couldn't care less, turns out to have organized his people rather carefully for situations that nobody fully understands, him included.
The hero's trap
River lands in Slough House because of a heroic failure. In a training exercise at Stansted Airport he decides he has spotted the target, goes all in, and is wrong. He never really stops doing this. In season 4 his grandfather shoots an intruder and gives his own version of what happened. River takes it at face value and heads off, mostly alone, to run it down. The story he picks is always the simple one, and it always has him in the middle of it setting things right. He's moving before he has checked any of it.
Jennifer Garvey Berger has a name for what's going on. She writes about leadership mindtraps, the mental shortcuts that work fine when life is predictable and steer us wrong when it isn't. River is caught in about four of them. He wants a simple story with a villain. He treats feeling right as if it were the same as being right. He needs to control how things turn out, so asking for help registers as losing. And because he's trying to redeem himself, every problem becomes a test of whether he's any good.
We meet Rivers constantly. They tend to be the high performers, the ones already on somebody's succession slate, and their organizations reward the heroics. In The End of Leadership As We Know It, Dan and his co-author Steve Garcia call this the Superhero Trap. Heroics are a reasonable bet when you know where the fight is going to be. In a complex environment you don't, and the fight has usually moved by the time you get there. What worries us more is what it does to the people watching. The book's line is that "No matter how charismatic, a leader's heroism is inherently disempowering." People learn to wait for the rescue.
What Lamb actually does
Let's be clear that Lamb is nobody's role model. His contempt for his team is not an act, and anyone who treated staff the way he does should lose the job. Set the manners aside, though, and look at how he has things arranged. It's a different model from River's in at least four ways.
He doesn't marry a theory. In Dead Lions, a washed-up Cold War asset turns up dead on a bus and the Park is happy to call it a heart attack. Lamb doesn't buy it, but he also doesn't go chase it alone the way River would. He gets several lines of inquiry going with different people on each, and the pieces only come together late in the season. Dave Snowden would recognize this. His Cynefin framework separates complicated problems, which experts can analyze, from complex ones, where cause and effect only make sense afterward. For the complex kind his advice is to run a handful of small, safe-to-fail probes at once, see how the system reacts, and amplify whatever works. Betting everything on one hypothesis tells you, eventually, whether you were right. It doesn't teach you much else.
He also spends a surprising amount of his time at the edge of his team, dealing with the Park. He horse-trades with Diana Taverner. He bluffs her, holds things back, and takes the blame when something goes wrong, and what he gets in return is room for his people to work. Mary Uhl-Bien's complexity leadership research describes this job well. In her terms, organizations need administrative leadership for structure, efficiency, and control, and they need adaptive leadership, which is the improvising and problem-solving done by people close to the action. Those two rub against each other constantly. Enabling leadership is the work of managing that friction so the adaptive work has space and its results make it back into the formal system. The Park is about as administrative as it gets, the slow horses out in the field are the adaptive part, and Lamb is the enabler.
The third thing is easier to miss. Slough House is the periphery of MI5, staffed by people the center has stopped listening to, and yet it keeps spotting what matters before the Park does. Michael Arena's research on adaptive space predicts exactly that. New insight tends to start at the edges of an organization's network, with people who have ties outside the dominant core, and it tends to die there too unless somebody carries it back in. That somebody is Lamb. He takes what his exiles notice seriously, and he picks his moment to put it in front of the Park.
And he mostly stays out of the way. When Lamb does step in, it tends to be at the moment that decides things, and then he backs off again. In between, his people flounder and sometimes fail, which is a big part of why they get better as the series goes on. It also means Lamb isn't the only one leading. Catherine Standish supplies the care, the memory, and the order that he won't, and over time the horses start leading each other. You can see it when Catherine is taken in season 3. These are people who barely trusted one another in season 1, and they move as a team.
The moment the hero can't
There's a real-world version of this in the book. Walt Rakowich became CEO of Prologis, the industrial real estate company, in 2008 after the board fired his predecessor. A few months in, the company was still close to bankruptcy. In the middle of a critical meeting with his leadership team he called a break, went for a walk, and fainted from the stress. When the meeting started again he had no plan. He told them, more or less, that he didn't know what to do and that he needed their help.
Things turned on that admission. The team rallied, bought time with the creditors, and pulled the business around, and by the time Rakowich retired Prologis was profitable and the largest firm in its industry. Nobody should take from this that you wait until you pass out to ask for help. What we take from it is that as long as Rakowich was trying to carry the whole thing himself, the company was working with a fraction of what its people knew.
Five practices for leading like an organizer
1. Notice when you've become the hero of your own story. Feeling certain that you, personally, have to fix this is worth noticing, but it's information about you and not an instruction. Try to picture the version where someone else solves it, or where several people do it together. If you can't come up with one, that's probably Berger's control trap or ego trap talking.
2. Run more than one line at once. When a situation is complex, don't pick one theory and throw most of your people at it. Put small teams on competing hypotheses and keep the experiments cheap. Decide ahead of time what you'd need to see to double down on one, and what would make you drop it.
3. Spend your energy at the boundary. A lot of the most useful senior leadership work never gets seen by the team. It's protecting room to experiment, translating between the adaptive edge and the formal system, and soaking up pressure from above so people can get on with it. A calendar full of the team's own work is a decent sign you're not doing enough of this.
4. Listen hardest to the periphery. The people who don't fit the official picture often see the shift first. That might be a new hire, someone on the front line, or the colleague everybody finds difficult. Give their observations a real route to the people making decisions, and make brokering them part of somebody's job.
5. Save your interventions. Sometimes the hero move is the right one. It should be rare, because each time you swoop in, the team learns that the real decisions get made above them. Step in when the stakes call for it, and then get back out so that the outcome belongs to them.
Building Slough Houses
Most organizations have plenty of Rivers and keep promoting them. What we'd ask senior leaders is whether they're also building any Slough Houses, meaning places where the people who don't fit the official picture can notice something, act on it, and get enough cover for it to matter.
River will keep trying to save the day, and we'll keep enjoying watching him try. Lamb is building a team that can do it without him. When the fight moves faster than any one person can run, that's the job that counts.
Sources and Further Reading
- Arena, M. J. (2018). Adaptive Space: How GM and Other Companies Are Positively Disrupting Themselves and Transforming into Agile Organizations. McGraw-Hill.
- Garcia, S. and Fisher, D. (2023). The End of Leadership As We Know It: What It Takes to Lead in Today's Volatile and Complex World. Wiley.
- Garvey Berger, J. (2019). Unlocking Leadership Mindtraps: How to Thrive in Complexity. Stanford University Press.
- Herron, M. (2010 to present). The Slough House novels. Adapted for television as Slow Horses (2022 to present), Apple TV.
- Snowden, D. J. and Boone, M. E. (2007). "A Leader's Framework for Decision Making." Harvard Business Review, November 2007.
- Uhl-Bien, M., Marion, R., and McKelvey, B. (2007). "Complexity Leadership Theory: Shifting Leadership from the Industrial Age to the Knowledge Era." The Leadership Quarterly, 18(4).
Continue Reading
More from the Journal.
The Slow Horses Guide to Risk
Nobody in the room has different information. They have different temperaments. What Slough House teaches leadership teams about risk temperament, and why they keep arguing about how worried to be.
Leadership Was Never Meant to Be a Solitary Endeavor
The myth of the lone leader is failing in the face of modern complexity. True resilience is built through collective intelligence and the courage to be seen by peers.
Deciding Without Certainty
Regent's Park has the map. Jackson Lamb keeps watching the territory. What Slow Horses teaches senior leaders about sensemaking when the facts won't hold still.
