← The EdgePoint Journal

Deciding Without Certainty

Why the search for certainty is failing senior executives, and what works instead

By Dan Fisher, PhD and Liz Weglarz

Early in his career, Dan worked for a large consulting firm that helped companies write strategic plans. They were handsome documents, full of charts and diagrams and written in a language few people outside the planning team could follow. In a real sense they were maps, showing where the company stood and the route to where it wanted to be. Their great weakness was an assumption buried so deep that nobody thought to question it: that the world would hold still long enough for the company to follow the route. It never did.

We have been thinking about those plans lately because we are both devoted fans of Mick Herron’s Slow Horses, the novels and the Apple TV series alike. If you already know Slough House, bear with us for a paragraph.

For everyone else, Slow Horses is set in a fictionalized version of MI5, the UK’s domestic intelligence service --- in this instance, a blend of our US FBI and CIA. Its heroes, if that is the right word, are a misfit gang of agents who have been sidelined after a botched operation or a career-ending mistake and exiled to Slough House, a shabby office where careers go to die. They answer to Jackson Lamb, a disheveled, flatulent, and spectacularly rude former field operative who appears to spend most of his working day asleep with his feet on the desk.

The series keeps cutting between Slough House and Regent’s Park, MI5’s gleaming headquarters. The Park has the budget and the technology, and it sees far more of the intelligence picture than anyone at Slough House ever will. It also has plans, and those plans have a habit of coming apart once events start moving. Lamb has almost none of the Park’s advantages, yet he is usually the first person to work out what is actually going on. He does it by building a rough theory from whatever is in front of him, paying close attention to the detail that doesn’t fit the official story, and revising as he goes. He never confuses the information he has with the answer.

What Lamb understands, and the Park keeps forgetting, is that the map is not the territory. A plan is a useful picture of reality, but it is still only a picture.

That distinction matters well beyond espionage. In our work with senior leaders, the hardest decisions are rarely the ones where information is missing altogether. They are the ones where the information is incomplete, keeps changing, or can be read more than one way, and a decision still has to be made by Thursday.

The ache for certainty

When The Conference Board surveyed more than 1,700 executives and board members worldwide for its 2026 C-Suite Outlook, one theme ran through nearly everything they said. U.S. CEOs ranked uncertainty as their leading economic concern, and executives around the world described a landscape being reshaped by geopolitical instability, rapid policy shifts, AI disruption, and changing labor markets.

None of that will surprise the leaders we work with. They rarely lack intelligence or information; most of them have more data than any reasonable person could absorb. What they were trained to believe is that enough rigorous analysis will eventually produce the right answer, and for most of their careers that belief served them well. The sequence they mastered, gathering the data and analyzing it carefully before deciding and executing, works as long as the past is a decent guide to the future. When the environment is moving quickly, the analysis can be out of date before anyone finishes reading it.

In The End of Leadership As We Know It: What It Takes to Lead in Today's Volatile and Complex World, Steve Garcia and Dan argued that data can become a trap in disruptive conditions. Data feels precise and objective, which is exactly why a leader looking for something solid to hold onto can lean on it too hard. Most organizational data describes what has already happened, and even real-time information has to be interpreted by someone. The danger is that a leader ends up with an increasingly confident picture of a world that is already disappearing. That is the Park’s recurring failure, and we see a version of it in executive teams more often than we would like.

Best practices and strategic plans create a similar problem. A borrowed framework is useful when your situation resembles the ones it was built from, and a plan is useful as long as the assumptions underneath it still hold. In genuinely complex situations, neither condition can be taken for granted. The variables interact in ways no framework anticipated, and the assumptions drift while the plan sits on the shelf looking authoritative. Followed uncritically, either one can steer you wrong, or steer you toward exactly the answer your competitors have already reached.

Sensemaking is the alternative

The alternative is what organizational researchers call sensemaking: building a working theory of the situation and treating it as provisional. That means deciding which factors really matter and how they relate to one another, forming a view of what may be shifting underneath the surface, and knowing in advance what you would expect to see if your theory were right. Analysis is part of it, but so is judgment, and so is a willingness to imagine explanations you would rather not consider. The hardest part is usually staying curious about the information that doesn’t fit what you already believe.

This is more or less what Lamb does every time. He starts with a scrap, such as an old contact from his Berlin days turning up dead on a bus, builds a theory that fits what he has, and drops it without visible embarrassment when it stops fitting. The Park tends to settle on an interpretation early and then defend it. Once Regent’s Park has decided what a situation is, a remarkable amount of institutional energy goes into proving itself right.

A useful business example comes from Intel. By the early 1980s, the company’s memory-chip business, the foundation of its identity, was under intense pressure from Japanese competitors. Intel’s leaders had plenty of data. What they struggled with was what that evidence meant for a business so central to how Intel understood itself.

Andy Grove eventually put a question to CEO Gordon Moore. If the board threw them out and brought in a new CEO, what would that person do? Moore answered that a new leader would probably get Intel out of memory chips. Grove’s reply was simple: why shouldn’t the two of them walk out the door, come back in, and do it themselves?

They still could not know how the market would evolve or whether a future built on microprocessors would work. But by stepping outside Intel’s history for a moment, they could see the evidence they already had in a different light and start acting on it. Lamb would have appreciated the move. Grove didn’t ask for another report. He changed where the two of them were standing when they looked at the reports they already had.

Saying “I don’t know yet”

There is another pressure that makes this kind of thinking hard, which is that the perceived margin for error keeps shrinking. Senior decisions get scrutinized by boards, investors, employees, regulators, and the public. Leaders feel pushed to act boldly and punished for acting wrongly at the same time. Under those conditions, waiting for more certainty can feel like the safe choice, even when the delay carries real costs of its own.

And there is something that rarely comes up in strategy conversations: the barrier to leading differently is often as emotional as it is intellectual. The heroic model of leadership taught executives to project confidence at all times, and many of them privately fear that saying “I don’t know yet” will read as weakness. Slow Horses has a sharp take on this. Diana Taverner, running operations from the Park, spends much of the series managing how things look to the people above her, and her need to appear in control drives some of her worst decisions. Lamb, whatever else you might say about him, has never once tried to look impressive.

In our experience, teams handle uncertainty far better than their leaders expect. They can usually tell when certainty is being performed for their benefit. A leader who says, “Here is my current theory, here is what would change my mind, and here is how we will find out,” tends to earn more trust than one who pretends to know, because the team can see the thinking and knows there is room to adjust.

Five practices for deciding without certainty

1. Hold your plan as a hypothesis. Instead of asking whether the plan is right, ask what would have to be true for it to work, and what you would expect to see if it started going wrong. Writing those signals down at the outset makes a surprising difference. Leaders who treat plans this way update faster and spend less energy defending their egos, because changing course becomes part of the process rather than an admission that the first call was a mistake.

2. Build options, and test them small. A good plan is less a prediction than a set of options you can reach for as events unfold. Where the stakes allow it, try an idea on a smaller scale before making the larger and more expensive commitment. The useful question shifts from how to get it right the first time to what you can learn before the bigger decision arrives.

3. Know which kind of problem you are facing. Complicated problems, like engineering a bridge, yield to expertise, analysis, and established methods. Complex problems, like shifting a culture or entering an unpredictable market, behave differently because cause and effect often become clear only in hindsight. Bringing tools built for complicated problems to complex ones is a mistake we see senior teams make often, and it can be expensive. In Slow Horses terms, it is the desk officer at the Park insisting that the operation follow the plan while the agent on the street is looking at something else entirely.

4. Ground yourself when the map fails. When the outside world offers no reliable guide, your internal one matters more. Leaders who are clear about what they are trying to accomplish and what they will not compromise make faster and more consistent decisions under pressure, because they are not rebuilding their reasoning from scratch every time circumstances change. The destination can stay fixed while the route changes many times over.

5. Think out loud with people who owe you nothing. Sensemaking is hard to do alone. Our own assumptions are difficult to see, especially when everyone around us shares them. The executives we see handle uncertainty well usually have trusted people outside their reporting lines, their function, or even their company who will push back on how they are reading the situation. The point is not reassurance. It is finding someone who will tell you what you are missing.

Trading the answer for the question

Nothing in The Conference Board’s findings suggests that uncertainty is going away, and the leaders we admire most have stopped waiting for it to. They stay open to new information and adjust without much drama when the situation shifts. They have given up the comfort of having the answer in exchange for the discipline of asking better questions.

Confidence under uncertainty doesn’t come from knowing you are right. It comes from trusting that you will find out quickly, and that you will adjust when you do.

Those strategic plans from earlier in Dan’s career weren’t useless, as it turns out. The problem was that people treated them as the territory when they were only ever a map.

Regent’s Park has the map. Lamb keeps watching the territory. In a world where the territory changes faster than the map can be redrawn, that may be the most important leadership capability of all.

Sources and Further Reading

  • The Conference Board. “C-Suite Outlook 2026: Uncertainty and Opportunity” and accompanying survey release, January 2026.
  • Garcia, S. and Fisher, D. (2022) The End of Leadership As We Know It: What It Takes to Lead in Today's Volatile and Complex World (Wiley)
  • Grove, Andrew S. Only the Paranoid Survive: How to Exploit the Crisis Points That Challenge Every Company. Currency/Doubleday, 1996.
  • Herron, Mick. The Slough House novel series; and Slow Horses, Apple TV.

Ideas travel further inside a community.

EdgePoint members work through pieces like this with peers carrying comparable weight.